|Portrayed by Tim Guinee|
|Relatives:|| Nina (wife)|
|First appearance:||"Silly Season"|
|Latest appearance:||"Loser Edit"|
Andrew Wiley is an old friend of Cary Agos from the Innocence Project in 2008. After his wife, Nina, formed a company, he became a stay-at-home husband for their daughter. He then began taking his daughter to an indoor play center where other formerly successful dads now also take care of their children after their wives became successful.